Like Fahey, Collins had a knack for schmoozing with reporters, appearing to confide confidential information while never revealing a secret the department wanted hidden. Although both were chummy towards reporters, there was no question where their loyalty lay. It was, as it should be, to the NYPD.
Collins’ greatest contribution, however, was using his people skills to contain the damage that Mode caused the department by disappearing for hours, refusing to return phone calls and losing her temper at her staff and at reporters. Despite his efforts, it became obvious to all at Police Plaza and City Hall that something was wrong with DCPI. Everyone knew Mode was the problem but, since she was Safir’s choice, no one wanted to do what needed to be done.
Then, in the finest NYPD tradition, a solution presented itself: Safir spared an incompetent but well-connected higher-up and punished a competent lower-ranking officer.
You guessed it. Safir made Collins the scapegoat. In 1999, he transferred him from DCPI, the night after he had laid out $450 of his own money to host reporters and DCPI staff at the annual office Christmas party.
Both Mode and Safir had attended the party, but gave no indication then that Collins was out. He was so taken by surprise and so hurt that, when I commiserated with him a few days later, his voice choked.
Richard Freedman, Chair of the Department of Management at NYU’s Leonard N. Stern School of Business, called Collins’ ouster “organizational politics at its dirtiest.”
“The boss has to do something so you find the appropriate victim. It’s pure façade,” he said.
Now guess who replaced him as commanding officer? None other than Fahey. His friendship with Safir’s First Deputy Pat Kelleher, has resuscitated Fahey’s career. It had taken four years but he had come full circle. He was now a Deputy Chief, commanding officer again of DCPI.
Fahey remained at DCPI when Kerik became police commissioner. It turned out that he had been Kerik’s commanding officer when Kerik was a rookie in Midtown South precinct.
For Kerik, who’d never risen above third-grade detective, Fahey was the only chief he knew. During Kerik’s short tenure as police commissioner, Fahey was as influential as any chief in the NYPD.
In fact, Kerik tried to reward Fahey by making him Chief of Detectives. Giuliani vetoed that, so Fahey settled for second best — Chief of Manhattan detectives with a promotion to Assistant Chief. His most notable move: assigning homicide detectives to roust Fox News employees after Kerik’s girlfriend, Judith Regan, falsely accused them of stealing her cell phone.
But with Kelly’s return as police commissioner, Fahey’s days were numbered. Kelly had no use for anyone close to Kerik. He wanted people loyal only to him. At Fahey’s retirement dinner, Kerik attended, as did Bratton, who flew in from Los Angeles where he is police chief. Kelly was a no-show.
So what about Collins? Promoted to Deputy Chief, he returned under Kelly to DCPI. Like Fahey, he again served with distinction and loyalty. He was so loyal that for the past couple of years he has refused to return Your Humble Servant’s phone calls.
When, apparently on Kelly’s directive, the department refused to renew Your Humble Servant’s press card, it was Collins who signed the order.
Why has Collins decided to retire? He did not return a call to his office on Saturday. Deputy Commissioner Paul Browne did not return a call seeking an explanation.