Wired in Newark
March 17, 2008
Fans of the fictional, Baltimore-based television series “The
Wire” can catch a real-life version now playing out in Newark,
New Jersey.
The cast: Newark’s Mayor Cory Booker, his Chief of Staff Pablo
Fonseca, Police Chief Anthony Campos, and Police Director Garry McCarthy.
On the TV. version of “The Wire,” Baltimore’s reform
mayor wins election by promising to attack crime and reform the police
department as the key to rejuvenating the city.
In real-life Newark, Mayor Booker won election in 2006 by promising
to attack crime and reform the police department as the key to rejuvenating
Newark.
Eighteen months ago, he hired former NYPD Deputy Commissioner McCarthy
as Newark’s civilian Police Director. Say what you will about Garry — and
this column has said plenty, specifically about his dust up with the
Palisades Parkway police over a parking ticket for his daughter — when
it comes to policing, he’s the real deal.
Booker also hired McCarthy’s former boss, ex-NYPD Commissioner
Howard Safir, to study the Newark P.D. Safir cited potential for conflict
between the civilian Police Director [McCarthy] and the department’s
top uniformed chief [Campos] beneath him. In perhaps the only intelligent
recommendation Safir ever made, he noted that the city charter — or
whatever it is that sanctions the arrangement — might need change.
O.K., so McCarthy takes over in Newark. He works round the clock. [No
one ever accused Garry of laziness.] Crime plummets. Earlier this year,
Newark experiences a stretch of 43 consecutive days without a murder.
So far this year, there have been only five, compared to 18 in 2007.
But there’s that conflict at the top. Ostensibly it’s between
McCarthy and Campos, a Newark police department veteran, who is known
as Elvis for his wavy hair and sideburns. Two weeks ago, McCarthy transferred
two dozen officers. Campos overturned the transfers.
What? The Number Two counters an order from Number One? That takes guts,
or a death wish.
Well, it turns out Campos was ordered to block the transfer by Booker’s
Chief of Staff Fonseca. He’s another longtime Booker political
supporter. According to the Newark Star-Ledger, he wants to be consulted
on all department personnel moves. And Campos is said to be his guy.
By ordering Campos to block McCarthy’s transfer Fonseca is taking
a giant step. He’s placing Booker in an embarrassing situation
and Campos in a vulnerable one.
Last week, McCarthy, who is not known for his delicacy — recall
his failure to follow the advice of NYPD Chief of Department Joe Esposito
and accept the Palisades Parkway police’s summons and get out of
there as quickly as he could — upped the ante. He suspended Campos
for five days.
Booker was forced to publicly back McCarthy, though, apparently as a
sop to Fonseca, he said Campos would draw his pay while suspended. He
also called the dispute between McCarthy and Fonseca “healthy tension.” The
hell it is. Sooner or later, and probably sooner rather than later, Booker
is going to have to choose between his Police Director and his Chief
of Staff. Campos could become the scapegoat.