The NYPD's Reward, and Price, for Loyalty
July 31, 2006
Today as you read this column, Michael Collins —
who, with recently retired chief Thomas Fahey, has been the face of the
New York City police department for more than a decade — will be
promoted to Assistant Chief.
Not only that but Collins will remain the commanding
officer of DCPI, as the department’s Office of Public Information
is known.
Collins’ promotion [in the NYPD, Assistant Chief
is a rank above Deputy Chief and one below its three-star super-chiefs]
is part morality tale, part a reflection of the vicissitudes of NYPD politics.
His remaining at DCPI reflects the importance Police
Commissioner Ray Kelly attaches to public relations — i.e., his
image.
[Just think. Two decades ago, before crime and terrorism
became political issues, DCPI was commanded by a captain.]
Like Fahey, Collins bleeds NYPD blue. No matter how
friendly or forthcoming he may appear to reporters, there is no question
where his loyalty lies — to the police department.
When Chief of Detectives William Allee retired in
2003 and sought to disinvite this reporter to his retirement dinner, it
was to Collins that Allee turned.
“The former chief of detectives asked me to
tell you not to attend his dinner," Collins said, although Newsday
[where Your Humble Servant then hung his hat] had purchased a $125 ticket.
"The chief says you might make some people uncomfortable,"
Collins added by way of explanation.
Like Fahey, Collins has also suffered for his loyalty
to the department.
The 6-foot-five-inch Collins, 50, joined DCPI under
former Commissioner Howard Safir in 1996. He was a natural — laid-back,
savvy, wry, and self-schooled. He received little help from his civilian
boss, Deputy Commissioner of Public Information Marilyn Mode, Safir’s
longtime friend, who was herself struggling in her position.
But with Safir’s deliberate misleading of the
media or worse, distrust between him and reporters grew so intense that
something had to give. Since Mode was Safir’s longtime friend, that
something was Collins.
Following DCPI’s annual Christmas party in 1999
— which Collins hosted and which virtually the city’s entire
press corps attended [along with two of Collins’ brothers, who are
even larger than he] Collins was sacked. Though his body language reflected
his shock and hurt, he never uttered a word of complaint. He never bad-mouthed
Mode or anyone else in the department.
Instead, he moved to Manhattan Detectives, replaced
at DCPI by Fahey, who had commanded the office under Safir’s predecessor,
William Bratton. Fahey himself had been sacked when then Mayor Rudolph
Giuliani fired Fahey’s civilian boss, John Miller, presumably because
Bratton’s press was better than his.
When Bernard Kerik succeeded Safir, Kerik promoted
Fahey to Assistant Chief. Then, after an abortive attempt to have him
replace Allee as Chief of Detectives, which Giuliani vetoed, Kerik did
the next best thing by Fahey, making him Chief of Manhattan Detectives.